Controversy Erupts Over Covering Mosque and Mazar in Haridwar

The recent decision by the administration in Haridwar, Uttarakhand, to cover a mosque and a mazar along the Kanwar Yatra route has sparked a significant controversy. The move, which was intended to prevent potential unrest during the annual pilgrimage, has drawn criticism from various quarters. This article explores the events leading up to the decision, the reactions from different stakeholders, and the implications for communal harmony in the region.

Background and Context

The Kanwar Yatra is an annual pilgrimage during which devotees of Lord Shiva, known as Kanwariyas, travel to collect water from the Ganges River and offer it at Shiva temples. The route taken by the pilgrims often passes through areas with diverse religious landmarks. In Haridwar, the administration decided to cover the Islamnagar Mosque and a nearby mazar with curtains. This action was reportedly taken to avoid any potential conflicts during the Yatra.

The Decision and Its Justification

Uttarakhand Tourism Minister Satpal Maharaj stated that the measure was implemented to ensure the smooth conduct of the Kanwar Yatra. He emphasized that the decision aimed to prevent any possible unrest, considering the heightened sensitivities around religious places during the pilgrimage. The move came in the wake of recent controversies, including disputes over the display of nameplates of shops during the Yatra.

Reactions and Controversy

The decision to cover the mosque and mazar was met with widespread criticism. Former Uttarakhand Chief Minister Harish Rawat condemned the action, questioning the rationale behind it. He expressed concern that such measures could create divisions among communities. Rawat was quoted saying, “When there are various temples, mosques, and churches on the way, it reflects India. Are Kanwar yatris so narrow-minded that if the shadow of a religious place of another faith falls on them, they will start avoiding it?”

People associated with the mosque and the mazar also voiced their disapproval. Shakeel Ahmed, associated with the mazar, stated that the administration had put up the curtains without informing them. He expressed confusion, noting that there had never been any issues with Kanwariyas in the past 40 years. Anwar Ali, the head of the mosque in Islamnagar, echoed similar sentiments, stating that there had been no prior discussion about the curtains.

Community and Local Reactions

Local residents and shopkeepers also expressed their concerns. Yunus, a local shopkeeper who has lived in the area for 60 years, mentioned that the administration’s decision was unprecedented. He noted that the Kanwariyas continued to shop in the area without any issues, despite the presence of the curtains. He questioned the necessity of such measures, which he believed had affected local businesses.

The Reversal of the Decision

Following the uproar and widespread criticism, the decision to cover the mosque and mazar was reversed. The administration removed the curtains, acknowledging the public’s concerns and the importance of maintaining communal harmony. This decision was seen as a positive step toward restoring peace and understanding among the different communities in the region.

Implications for Communal Harmony

The controversy surrounding the covering of the mosque and mazar highlights the sensitive nature of religious issues in India. It underscores the need for careful consideration and dialogue when making decisions that affect multiple communities. The incident serves as a reminder of the importance of fostering an environment of mutual respect and understanding, especially during events like the Kanwar Yatra, which draw large crowds and involve diverse groups of people.

The decision to cover the mosque and mazar on the Kanwar Yatra route in Haridwar and its subsequent reversal has brought attention to the delicate balance required to maintain communal harmony in India. It is crucial for authorities and communities to work together to ensure that such measures do not inadvertently create divisions. The incident serves as an opportunity for reflection and a call for unity and understanding among all citizens.

Aakhir Tak Editor-in-Chief

See Full Bio