Slum Tourism in India: Ethical Concerns and Controversies

Slum tourism has gained popularity in major Indian cities such as Delhi, Mumbai, and Bengaluru. This type of tourism involves guided tours of impoverished areas, showcasing the living conditions and daily lives of residents. But at what cost does this form of tourism come?

The concept of slum tourism was notably highlighted by the 2008 film “Slumdog Millionaire.” While the movie was a global hit and won eight Academy Awards, it also sparked controversy. Critics, including Tapeshwar Vishwakarma, argued that the film’s portrayal of slum dwellers violated their human rights and catered to a foreign gaze.

Today, slum tourism continues to attract visitors, offering a glimpse into the harsh realities faced by residents. However, the practice remains controversial. Supporters argue that it raises awareness about poverty and supports local economies. Critics, on the other hand, claim that it exploits residents and turns their hardships into a spectacle for wealthy tourists.

Historical Context

The origins of slum tourism date back to the late 19th century. According to a New York Times article from 1884, wealthy elites visited slums to understand the lives of the poor or to garner political support. This trend has evolved, and today, travel platforms like Agoda, TripAdvisor, and GetYourGuide promote slum tours in Indian cities.

The Rise of Slum Tours

Slum tourism gained momentum in 2003 when Chris Way, inspired by his visit to Rio de Janeiro’s favelas, teamed up with Krishna Pujari. Together, they founded Reality Tours and Travel in Mumbai. Their aim was to give back to the community by donating a significant portion of their earnings to local initiatives.

However, not all slum tours are driven by altruistic motives. While Reality Tours and Travel emphasizes community support, other companies may lack similar intentions.

Controversy and Ethical Dilemmas

In March 2024, US TikToker Tara Katims’ video documenting her Dharavi tour sparked backlash. Many criticized the portrayal of slum life as a form of entertainment. Reviews of slum tours are mixed; some find them educational, while others view them as intrusive.

A review on TripAdvisor highlights concerns about the cleanliness and safety of slum tours. Recommendations include wearing sturdy footwear, bringing hand sanitizers, and being cautious about personal belongings.

The Moral Debate

Madhu Singh, co-founder of the Pardada Pardadi NGO, argues that slum tourism is fundamentally flawed. She believes that showcasing poverty for entertainment is disturbing and suggests focusing on positive ways to uplift marginalized communities instead.

As slum tourism continues to grow, it raises important ethical questions. While it can provide insights into the lives of the less fortunate, it also risks exploiting their struggles. Balancing awareness and respect remains a key challenge in this controversial form of tourism.

Aakhir Tak Editor-in-Chief

See Full Bio