Elon Musk Sued for Delayed Disclosure of Twitter Stake

Aakhir Tak – In Shorts

1. Elon Musk has been sued by the SEC for failing to disclose his large Twitter stake promptly in 2022.
2. The SEC claims Musk delayed disclosing his 5% share purchase by 11 days, breaking securities law.
3. This delay enabled Musk to buy over $500 million worth of Twitter shares at lower prices.
4. After Musk’s disclosure, Twitter’s stock price rose by 27%, benefiting him financially.
5. Musk defends the suit, calling it a mere administrative error, and denies any fraud.

Aakhir Tak – In Depth

The SEC’s Lawsuit Against Musk
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a lawsuit against Elon Musk in 2023, accusing him of failing to disclose his 5% stake in Twitter in a timely manner. The SEC claims Musk violated federal securities laws by waiting 11 days longer than the legal requirement to inform the public. According to SEC regulations, any investor reaching a 5% threshold must disclose their holdings within 10 calendar days. Musk’s delay, the SEC argues, allowed him to buy more shares at artificially low prices, later disclosing his purchases in April 2022 when his stake had grown to 9.2%.

Impact of the Delay
When Musk finally made his purchases public, Twitter’s stock price surged by over 27%. This price hike was beneficial for Musk, who had already accumulated substantial shares. The SEC asserts that this delay constituted an unfair advantage, where Musk secured over $500 million worth of shares at lower market prices. This action created an artificial market distortion at the expense of other investors.

Musk’s Defense
In response to the SEC’s allegations, Musk and his legal team have dismissed the charges, framing the incident as an “administrative error” with no malicious intent. Musk’s lawyer described the case as an example of the SEC’s “multi-year harassment campaign” against the billionaire. Musk himself refuted accusations of fraud, calling the case a “sham” and stated that the delay was a mistake rather than a deliberate act to deceive other shareholders.

Further Lawsuits and Previous Conflicts
Musk is also facing legal action in federal court in Manhattan over the delayed disclosure of his Twitter stake. In those proceedings, Musk argued that it was implausible to claim his delay was aimed at defrauding Twitter shareholders. Legal experts have observed a significant history of tensions between Musk and the SEC. In 2018, Musk was sued by the SEC over his Twitter posts about taking Tesla private. He settled that case by agreeing to pay a $20 million civil penalty and other restrictions.

Musk’s Wealth and Power
Known for his ownership of companies like Tesla and SpaceX, Musk has an estimated net worth of 7 billion, making him the world’s richest person according to Forbes. His wealth far exceeds that of Amazon’s Jeff Bezos, valued at $232 billion. Musk’s financial and legal maneuvers have always been under scrutiny, given his high-profile status in tech industries.

Aakhir Tak – Key Takeaways to Remember

• SEC sued Elon Musk for failing to promptly disclose his 5% Twitter stake in 2022.
• The delay allowed Musk to buy $500 million of shares at reduced prices, impacting the market.
• Musk defended the lawsuit as a mere administrative mistake, not an attempt at fraud.
• The SEC’s charges include a request for civil fines and the disgorgement of gains Musk made unfairly.
• Musk continues to face additional lawsuits related to his ownership of Twitter and conflicts with the SEC.

Aakhir Tak Editor-in-Chief

See Full Bio